In July 1996, after a prior order of protection expired, plaintiff obtained a second order of protection against her former boyfriend in Bronx Criminal Court. She delivered the order to the Domestic Violence Unit at her local police precinct and asked that it be served on her former boyfriend. At that time, plaintiff met two officers, the individuals assigned to the unit. Plaintiff later received a telephone call from one of the officers confirming that her former boyfriend had been served with the court order.
According to plaintiff, about a week later, her former boyfriend telephoned her at around 5:00 PM on a Friday evening and threatened to kill her. The former boyfriend had made various threats in the past — threats that prompted plaintiff to secure an order of protection — but plaintiff viewed this threat as an escalation of his hostility because he had not previously threatened to kill her. A New York Criminal Lawyer said the plaintiff immediately left her apartment with her two young sons, planning to go to her grandmother’s house in the Bronx. On the way to her car, however, she stopped at a payphone and contacted the Domestic Violence Unit to alert the police to the latest threat by her former boyfriend. She contended that she spoke with one of the officers, who told her that she should return to her apartment and that the police would arrest her former boyfriend immediately.
After speaking to one of the officers, plaintiff returned to her apartment with her children where she remained for the rest of the evening. She did not hear from the police that evening, nor did she contact the precinct to inquire whether her former boyfriend had been located or arrested. The night passed without incident. A Queens Criminal Lawyer said the following day, a Saturday, plaintiff and her children remained in their apartment most of the day. At about 10:45 PM that evening, plaintiff stepped out of the apartment and into the hallway of her building intending to take out the garbage when she was confronted by her former boyfriend brandishing a gun. He ushered her back into the apartment doorway and shot her two or three times injuring her face and arm. The two children witnessed the shooting but were not physically harmed. The former boyfriend then turned the gun on himself and committed suicide.